Skip to Main Content
Publications

When Safety Concerns Become ADA Claims: Why "Regarded As" Still Matters

An employer can face an Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) "regarded as" claim even when the employee is not actually disabled. If an employer restricts work, delays a return from medical leave, or requires a fitness-for-duty exam based on assumptions about a perceived medical condition rather than objective, job-related evidence, it risks a discrimination claim. Recent federal appellate decisions show that these claims can move forward, including in safety-sensitive jobs.

Bottom Line Up Front: Tie every restriction, return-to-work decision, and medical inquiry to the essential functions of the job and evidence specific to the employee, rather than assumptions about a medical condition. Keep medical inquiries narrowly tailored and document the job-related reasons for each decision. The practical steps below can help employers reduce risk.

Employers are often required to make quick decisions when an employee seeks to return from medical leave, presents new work restrictions, or raises safety concerns in a safety-sensitive job. But quick decisions can create risk. Employers may face discrimination and failure-to-accommodate claims under the ADA if they act on assumptions about the employee's medical condition rather than objective, job-related information.

The ADA's "regarded as" prong gives employees a potential claim if the way an employer handles these issues suggests it believes, or is treating, the employee as disabled. Even when an employee ultimately does not qualify for ADA protection, this conduct can still give rise to an actionable claim and make an already complicated situation harder to navigate. This raises important questions for employers: when should an employer acknowledge that a condition is a disability and accommodate it, and how can it navigate these interactions without creating additional risk?

The ADA defines "disability" to include being "regarded as" having an impairment. Since the ADA Amendments Act, an employee can meet this test by showing that the employer took an action the ADA prohibits because of an actual or perceived physical or mental impairment, regardless of whether the impairment limits (or is seen as limiting) a major life activity. Put simply, the question often is not whether the employee actually had a serious disability, but whether the employer believed the employee had a medical condition and treated the employee worse because of it.

That distinction is important because a "regarded as" claim is not the same as an accommodation claim. An employee who is covered only under the "regarded as" prong generally is not entitled to a reasonable accommodation on that basis alone. But the employer can still be liable for discrimination if it takes adverse action based on a perceived impairment, unsupported medical assumptions, or general safety worries. Employers should therefore keep two questions separate: whether the employee is entitled to an accommodation, and whether the employer is taking action because of a perceived impairment.

Recent federal appellate decisions show how this risk can play out in practice. In one recent decision, the Eighth Circuit revived a "regarded as" ADA claim where the employer restricted an employee from returning to his prior job for five years based on concerns that a traumatic brain injury created an increased risk of seizures. The court held that a jury could find the employer saw him as currently impaired and acted on that perception. In another, the Eleventh Circuit likewise allowed an ADA claim to proceed where the employer knew the employee was on anxiety-related leave, the leave was for a definite three-week period, and the employee testified that he was ready to return on his scheduled date. Together, these cases underscore the risk surrounding medical leave, return-to-work restrictions, and safety-based exclusions when an employer acts on medical assumptions rather than a documented, individualized assessment of the employee's ability to perform the job.

Fitness-for-duty exams and medical inquiries present another potential risk area. The ADA generally prohibits medical examinations or disability-related inquiries of current employees unless they are job-related and consistent with business necessity. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission's (EEOC's) ADA regulations permit a medical exam or inquiry of a current employee only when that standard is met, while allowing inquiries into the employee's ability to perform job-related functions. The EEOC's guidance explains that fitness-for-duty exams may be appropriate when needed to determine whether the employee can still perform essential job functions, or when required by medical standards or safety requirements that are themselves consistent with the ADA. The FMLA also places its own limits on these exams.

Safety concerns are legitimate, but they must be tied to objective evidence. The ADA defines a "direct threat" as a significant risk to health or safety that cannot be eliminated by reasonable accommodation. The statute also permits qualification standards that require an individual not to pose a direct threat in the workplace, but those standards must be applied in a way that is job-related and consistent with business necessity. Employers therefore should avoid relying on generalized concerns unless those concerns are supported by current medical information, the position's essential functions, and the actual risks presented by the job.

Practical Steps for Employers

Before restricting an employee's work, delaying a return, or requiring a fitness-for-duty exam, employers can take several practical steps to reduce ADA risk.

  1. Start with the job, not the diagnosis. Identify the essential functions at issue and document why the employee's condition or restrictions may affect those functions.
     
  2. Use objective evidence. Avoid decisions based on assumptions, fear, or stereotypes about a medical condition.
     
  3. Limit medical inquiries. Ask only for information needed to determine whether the employee can perform job-related functions or whether a lawful fitness-for-duty exam is justified. Focus on restrictions, not conditions.
     
  4. Keep accommodation and "regarded as" issues separate. An employee covered only under the "regarded as" prong may not be entitled to an accommodation, but that does not permit an adverse action based on a perceived impairment.
     
  5. Train managers on language. Managers should avoid offhand comments suggesting the company is acting because the employee is medically risky, impaired, or unsafe, unless the concern is tied to specific job duties and objective facts.

If you have questions about ADA "regarded as" claims, return-to-work decisions, or fitness-for-duty exams, please contact Jonathan C. Hancock, Chris Biller, or any member of the Firm's Labor & Employment Group.

Email Disclaimer

NOTICE: The mailing of this email is not intended to create, and receipt of it does not constitute an attorney-client relationship. Anything that you send to anyone at our Firm will not be confidential or privileged unless we have agreed to represent you. If you send this email, you confirm that you have read and understand this notice.
Cancel Accept